Cover of the Ewan McColl classic, at the original speed for once. So I know covering a classic like this is pretty dumb -- how you gonna compete with
Johnny Cash,
Peggy Seeger and
Roberta Flack? But I was really curious about something I read, so I wanted to try an experiment.
Apparently Ewan MacColl uniformly hated all covers of this song (
Elvis' mangling of it in particular), not least because they all played it much too slow. Roberta Flack's version, which really broke the song into the mainstream, is 4'15 or so. Johnny Cash's version is a hair under 4'00.
But Ewan McColl's original was about 2'30. However, it's nowhere to be found. I really wondered how the song would work back at that speed.
Secondly, and related, when it's taken so slowly, the harmonic structure of the song barely holds together. The chords seem almost arbitrary. I wondered if speeding it up would reveal a bit more about the structure of the song. Which it really did... it turns out to be quite a conventional piece, much easier to learn at the original tempo.
Finally, I wondered if the mournful, dirge-like quality it has when played so slowly would dissipate, and what would remain. I'm not sure yet. I do quite like the 6/8 feel, which just emerged as I was fiddling with the guitar part, seems to make the whole thing flow.
There are lots more manglings on YouTube, including versions by Alison Moyet, Celine Dion, Peter Paul & Mary, Stereophonics, and everyone else.
posted by peterkins at 9:46 AM on June 24, 2010